Welcome to Isabella's
Isabella's in Newcastle, Wyoming, is a hidden culinary gem that transcends typical small-town dining. Renowned primarily for its diverse pizza offerings, the restaurant impresses with a well-rounded menu featuring standout dishes like steak egg rolls and cranberry salads, both receiving high praise from patrons. Guests rave about the generous toppings and perfectly crisp crusts of their pizzas. The inviting atmosphere, characterized by a rustic saloon vibe and friendly service, enhances the dining experience. Whether you're indulging in delectable appetizers or savoring their signature burgers, Isabella's promises an exceptional meal that makes it worth the visit, time and again.
- 12 S Sumner Ave, Newcastle, WY 82701, United States Hotline: +1 307-746-3500
Welcome to Isabella's, a true gem hidden in the heart of Newcastle, Wyoming. Located at 12 S Sumner Ave, Newcastle, WY 82701, this delightful eatery transcends the typical dining experience you might expect from a small town. With a focus on pizza, Isabella's offers a surprising array of dishes that cater to a variety of palates, making it a must-visit destination for food lovers.
The ambiance strikes a perfect balance between a cozy country kitchen and a rustic saloon, creating an inviting atmosphere. As you walk in, you're greeted with the friendly faces of the staff who are eager to make your visit memorable. The service here is consistently praised; many customers mention the staff's attentiveness and engaging demeanor, contributing to a warm dining experience.
Now, let’s delve into the food — the true star of the show. Isabella's boasts an impressive menu loaded with options that will tantalize any taste bud. The steak egg roll appetizer comes highly recommended, filled with an irresistible mix of meat, peppers, and onions, served alongside a delectable Thai sauce. Customers rave about its delicious flavor, awarding it top marks.
For pizza lovers, Isabella's selections are a revelation. The meat lovers pizza delivers a generous topping of meats and a perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio, while their Gouda Portabella mushroom pizza has been described as the best pizza ever by patrons, showcasing their commitment to quality ingredients and flavors. Guest reviews highlight the crisp, well-cooked crusts that enhance the overall pizza experience.
Savor the cranberry and blue cheese salad, a dish that has captured the hearts of many, noted for its fresh ingredients and harmonious flavors. The mushroom and sausage ravioli and a range of tantalizing appetizers, including jalapeño poppers, also receive high praise, making it clear that Isabella's is not just about pizza.
Don't forget to leave space for dessert! While patrons have noted the chocolate lava cake as a luxurious finish to their meal, it's the welcoming atmosphere, combined with the delightful selections, that will have you returning time and again. As one diner aptly put it, dining at Isabella's is perhaps one of the top decisions you can make during your travels through Wyoming.
So whether you're a local or just passing through, make your way to Isabella's. A culinary experience awaits you that’s well worth the stop. For more information or to make a reservation, give them a call at +1 307-746-3500. Discover why this small-town restaurant has become a beloved treasure in Newcastle!

For a small town, Newcastle does not have a great deal of eating places other than fast food. However, Isabella's is a jewel and would be worth driving out of the way to visit or stopping in Newcastle long enough to try this place. Predominantly, they seem to be a pizza restaurant, but with all of the options on their menu, they are far more diverse than I thought they would be. The steak egg roll appetizer (pictured) comes three to a plate and they are worth every bite. It is filled with meat, peppers, onions, and served with a Thai sauce. On a scale of 1-10, these were easily a 10. The best we have ever had. The spinach artichoke dip (pictured) was also a 10 out of 10 and comes with little pieces of like Texas toast cut up into smaller bite-size squares. They were toasted just right so they were not overly crunchy, but also did not immediately go soggy when covered in the artichoke dip. I did the fish and chips (pictured) and while the fries seem to be overly done, they were actually the right consistency. Outside was a little crisper, but soft and hot on the inside. The fish though was a tad on the bland side compared to the other dishes we got, but would definitely get it again. Wife got the cranberry and blue cheese salad as a main dish (pictured) and she said it was one of the best she has ever eaten and rated it 8-9 out of 10. The day we were there, it was a little warmer, but there was outside seating available. In some ways, I wish we would have sat outside, but the flies that day were bad and there were quite a few in the restaurant as well. While they have a couple of desserts on the menu, we did not try them. The service was good and our waitress was friendly enough to engage in some small talk even when the restaurant started to fill up. We would DEFINITELY go here again on our next visit, and probably on multiple days.

Delicious cranberry salad and mushroom and sausage ravioli. Everything was perfectly hot, came quickly and accurately as ordered. Server was friendly, fast, and easy to talk to. Our friends ' pizza was amazing and generous toppings, crisp crust, and they even got half of it with mushrooms and the other half clear of them

This place is fantastic. Appetizer of jalapeno poppers was fantastic, had one of the best burgers I’ve had in Wyoming and we shared a delicious chocolate lava cake. Highly, highly recommend!

We stopped in for some pizza. Never eaten at this restaurant before. Was at the bar once and found out to be a very pleasant experience. Decided to try their Pizza. We ordered the meat lovers Pizza. I highly recommend this pizza. Exceptional distribution of cheese sauce ratio. They were very generous with the meat. Undercarriage the pizza was firm. Slightly Krispy. Very flavorful. In my opinion the best pizza I've tasted in the Black hills. Very pleasant atmosphere. Staff was very busy. I noticed they were very attentive and pleasant to everyone. Compliments to the person who made this pizza.

The service was quick and friendly, and everything we ordered tasted amazing!

My wife said that the Gouda Portabella mushroom pizza was the best pizza she’s ever had! We got the ale crust, but they also offered crispy crust and a gluten free option. We also got the delicious ravioli, but we both agree that the pizza was the clear winner. We tried ordering the pierogies, but they were out. We’ll have to come back for those! Brandi at the bar was very helpful and friendly. The whole place had a positive, welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant side has a country kitchen look and the bar side is more rustic saloon. We went on half-price wine and whiskey Wednesday, which was a nice surprise. We will most definitely be returning to Isabella’s!

Fantastic little eatery nestled in a small Wyoming town. We had the jalepeno poppers, Thanksgiving melt, pizza burger, and lava cake and it was all great!

Good food, good waitress, friendly staff. Just stopped through Wyoming and decided to eat here and we are glad we did, probably a top 10 decision I’ve ever made